- Post category:House styles
George Nicola
George is a seasoned interior designer and property marketing strategist with over 13 years of experience. He specializes in transforming properties into visually stunning spaces, helping clients recognize the potential and beauty in each property. With an impressive international client base of exciting projects throughout Europe and America.
George Nicola from TALLBOX: A barn is a traditional agricultural structure designed primarily for storage and livestock, while a barndominium combines living quarters with workspace in a hybrid format. You’ll find barns typically use wood construction with asphalt or metal roofing, old stone barns with stone walls and roofs or metal sheds, whereas barndominiums feature steel posts and metal components throughout designed for living from the start.
Old barns, steeped in history and tradition, are increasingly being repurposed into livable spaces with modern features.
This transformation, known as barn conversion or barn renovation, involves revamping the original rustic structure to accommodate contemporary living while maintaining its unique character.
The process often involves preserving the barn’s original features such as exterior, structural posts, floors, and ceiling beams, while incorporating modern amenities and materials.
In contrast, barndominiums blend modern amenities with multifunctional spaces, offering customizable options like mechanized systems and energy-efficient features. While both structures can last 40-100+ years, their distinct purposes and materials warrant careful consideration of your specific needs and long-term objectives.
Table of Contents
Key Differences between Barn and Barndominium?
Barns and barndominiums represent two distinct yet overlapping architectural concepts. While both structures share a rustic aesthetic and rural origins, their purposes, designs, and functionalities diverge significantly.
Understanding these differences is essential for individuals considering either structure for agricultural, residential, or mixed-use applications.arns and barndominiums represent two distinct yet overlapping architectural concepts.
While both structures share a rustic aesthetic and rural origins, their purposes, designs, and functionalities diverge significantly. Understanding these differences is essential for individuals considering either structure for agricultural, residential, or mixed-use applications.
Barns are traditional agricultural buildings designed to store equipment, hay, grain, and house livestock. These structures have been staples of rural landscapes for centuries, serving purely functional purposes.
Materials and Construction Barns are typically constructed from wood or metal, emphasizing durability and simplicity. Their designs often feature open, large spaces to accommodate agricultural storage needs, with minimal attention to insulation, aesthetics, or modern utilities.
How are barns used today?
Barns today are used not only for housing livestock, storing crops, and sheltering farm equipment but at as a barnhomes. They are also increasingly being utilised for adaptive reuse, such as event venues, residential conversions, and cultural centres. An example of this is the case of a barn in the United Kingdom that has been repurposed as a wedding venue, while maintaining its original rustic charm and structural integrity, or a metal barn conversion into separate living units (apartments).
Common Features and Limitations
- Lack of insulation and modern utilities like plumbing or HVAC systems.
- Open layouts optimized for storage and livestock.
- Minimal amenities prioritizing function over comfort.
Barndominiums blend the utilitarian features of barns with the comforts of modern living spaces. These hybrid structures often serve as both homes and functional barns, catering to individuals who seek a mix of rural charm and contemporary convenience.
Dual-Purpose Design Barndominiums are designed to accommodate residential needs alongside storage or workspace functionality. They often include bedrooms, bathrooms, kitchens, and living areas, with space allocated for hobbies, workshops, or even livestock.
Features and Residential Amenities
- Fully equipped with plumbing, electricity, and HVAC systems.
- Customizable interiors with modern designs.
- Multi-functional layouts suitable for various lifestyles.
Why Barndominiums Are Gaining Popularity?
Barndominiums attract individuals seeking rural living without sacrificing modern conveniences. They are particularly appealing to:
- Homeowners desiring unique, customizable living spaces.
- Professionals needing integrated workspace and residence.
- Hobbyists or entrepreneurs requiring storage or workshop areas alongside their homes.
Why Barn Conversions Are Gaining Popularity?
Barn conversions are gaining popularity due to several factors. The unique charm and character of these structures make them highly desirable, as each barn conversion is inherently different from one another. They often feature high vaulted ceilings and ample space, providing a touch of English country house charm without the associated maintenance costs and high heating bills that come with period properties.
Online searches for converted barns have increased, as buyers’ priorities have shifted towards countryside properties with outside spaces. There are many types of barns such as Pole Barn, Timber Frame, Stone Barn, Gambrel Roof, Monitor Barn, Bank Barn, Crib Barn, Round Barn, English Barn, Dutch Barn and more, that often represent unique architectural features.
Barn conversions often incorporate bi-fold doors that open onto the garden, making them ideal for indoor/outdoor living. Modern design techniques have made barn conversions more energy efficient, which is crucial in addressing the climate crisis.
What are the benefits and cost of converting a barn or buying a barndominium kit?
The benefits of converting a barn or buying a barndominium kit are numerous, with the primary advantage being cost-effectiveness. Converting an existing barn, on average, can range from $10 to $50 per square foot, allowing homeowners to save on building materials and labor costs, while purchasing a barndominium kit with assembly but excluding, can range from $45 to $160 per square foot, depending on customization levels.
Average 2,000 sq ft barndominium: $200,000-$300,000 vs. the average 2,000 sq ft converted barn can also come at $300,000 depending on the exact type of architecture; stone barns have the highest cost to convert.
Barndominium kits are low-maintenance options and are designed to be sturdy and sound, while converted barns might require long-term maintenance due to more rustic and natural look.
Both converted barns and barndominium kits can also increase property values and provide ample space for a shophouse or guest house.
However, one potential drawback is that kits may have limited design flexibility compared to custom-built homes or converted barns. Nonetheless, both options afford homeowners the opportunity to build a unique space tailored to their lifestyle.
The main benefit of buying a barndo kit is time for assembly, on average it takes a crew of 7 to assemble an entire 2,000 sq. ft kit for 10 working days (shell only),while converting a traditional barn into a home takes between 3 to 6 months for the 2,000 sq.ft.
The barn conversion route often faces more complications with zoning regulations, pest damage, and location limitations for the benefit of being very unique with high added value.
Barndominium kits offer more predictable costs and faster construction times, with modern amenities built in from the start.
Is a barn conversion a good investment?
Yes, a barn conversion can be a good investment, especially if the property is in a desirable location and the conversion is done to a high standard. Barn conversions are popular for their unique character and spacious interiors, which can attract buyers and renters alike.
For example, a well-executed barn conversion in a rural area can fetch a high resale value due to its charm and appeal. For example, with an investment of $400,000, just as building a traditional home in most states, a converted barn often gets valued at over a million dollars. For instance, a Connecticut developer coined the term “barndominium” to describe hybrid structures (converted traditional dutch barn), highlighting their growing appeal. Even Chip and Joanna Gaines featured a barn conversion valued at $1.2 million, underscoring the significant return on investment such projects can yield.
Is a barndominium conversion a good investment?
Yes, buying or building a barndominium can be a great investment, especially when it’s in a desirable location. Buying a barndominium ranges from $180,000 to $360,000 on average for a complete build without the land, compared to building a traditional home, which typically costs $400,000 for a standard architecture.
For example, a well-executed barn conversion in a rural area can fetch a high resale value due to its charm and appeal. For example existing banrdos appreciated 30% in 2 years ($205,000 to $270,100) in Alabama and the Upstate NY they gained $15,000 in just one after after they are build.
Old vs. New
Converting a barn involves taking an existing, often historic, structure and renovating it to create a modern living space. This approach allows individuals to preserve the original character and charm of the barn while incorporating modern amenities and design elements. The process of converting a barn can be complex, requiring careful planning and execution to ensure that the original structure is respected and enhanced.
Note: If you click on the link and buy the book, we might earn a small commission that will support us in writing these posts.
On the other hand, buying a barndo kit involves purchasing a pre-fabricated building package specifically designed to replicate the look and feel of a traditional barn. This approach offers a more streamlined and efficient process, as the kit typically includes all the necessary materials and instructions for assembly. Barndo kits can be customized to varying degrees, allowing individuals to select the features and design elements that best suit their needs and preferences.
Rustic vs. Modern
When considering a barn conversion or a new barndominium kit, it is essential to weigh the pros and cons of both options. Barn conversions offer the unique opportunity to preserve historical charm while incorporating modern amenities.
However, they may come with hidden expenses that can quickly add up, such as fumigation costs and re-engineering fees. Some structures may not be suitable for conversion due to foundation issues or structural integrity.
On the other hand, new barndominium kits can provide a cost-effective and efficient way to create a modern, energy-efficient living space. Post-and-beam kits offer superior durability over pole barns and can be highly customizable to suit individual lifestyle needs. Pre-engineered kits can also help eliminate potential headaches and cost overruns associated with custom designs.
What to select, old barn or new barndo kit?
Barns and barndominiums cater to different needs and lifestyles. Traditional barns remain indispensable for agricultural use, while barndominiums provide a multi-functional solution blending rustic charm with modern comfort. Choosing between the two depends on whether the priority lies in utility or a combination of living and working space.
